MCF-stack: Special Solutions of Mean Curvature Flow

§ 2.34 Ilmanen–White two-ended shrinkersC7322187A6FC

Earliest recorded reference: (first arXiv submission).

Paper credits and chronology

Paper credits are chronological and include every author of the cited papers. They identify sources, not exclusive discovery credit. Background-only citations do not determine the date of this example. A classical example may predate the references recorded here.

  1. Ilmanen–White — 2024-06-26 (first arXiv submission).
C7322187A6FC
4522A41972E4

For every integer $h\geq 2$, Ilmanen–White construct a smooth complete properly embedded self-shrinking surface $\Sigma _ h\subset \mathbb R^3$ of genus $h$ with exactly two ends. In their notation the initial wheel has genus $g=h+1$ and its tangent shrinker has genus $g-1$. The normalized flow is

\[ \vec H=-X^\perp /2,\qquad M_ t=\sqrt{-t}\, \Sigma _ h,\quad t<0. \]

There is no explicit formula: $\Sigma _ h$ is obtained as a tangent flow of a critical wheel.

  • This is a connected orientable noncompact surface, of dimension two and codimension one, with topology a closed genus-$h$ surface with two punctures. Both ends are smoothly asymptotically conical. The part above $P=\{ z=0\} $ is a graph over the unbounded component of $P\setminus \Sigma _ h$; the lower part is its reflection. The intersection with $P$ consists of $h+1$ disjoint smooth closed curves.

  • Its symmetries include reflection in $P$, reflections in the vertical planes at angles $j\pi /(h+1)$, and rotation through $2\pi /(h+1)$ about the vertical axis. The two cone links lie on opposite sides of the equator.

  • The authors construct a compact embedded initial surface of genus $h+1$ whose first singular time has exactly one singular point and this multiplicity-one tangent shrinker. Corollary 4.11 gives uniqueness of the tangent flow at that point, not uniqueness of all shrinkers with these topological data.

  • As $h\to \infty $, the shrinkers converge as varifolds to $2P$. After passage to a subsequence, convergence is smooth with multiplicity two away from one circle in $P$. For sufficiently large $h$, the initial compact wheel fattens immediately after its first singular time. No effective genus threshold for fattening is given.

  • The conical ends imply quadratic area growth and finite entropy, with $\lambda (\Sigma _ h)=F_{0,1}(\Sigma _ h)$. An exact value or a numerical upper bound for this particular construction is not recorded here. In particular, the entropy bound for Ketover's construction is not transferred to this one.

See [IlmanenWhite2025], version 3: Theorem 1.1 (PDF p. 2), Theorem 4.8 and Corollaries 4.9 and 4.11 (pp. 10–12), Theorem 7.6 (pp. 20–21), Theorem 9.4 (p. 26), and Theorem 10.5 (p. 31). The paper leaves open whether these shrinkers coincide with Ketover's doubled-plane examples. The interactive illustration follows the upper-graph and reflection description, with $h+1$ equatorial neck curves and two flaring ends. Its default genus $h=3$ matches the topology of Figure 1 (credited there to David Chopp); it does not reproduce Chopp's numerical surface. Neck shapes, lengths, and cone slopes are illustrative, and the shrinker equation has not been solved. The outer rims and cutaway edges are display truncations, not boundaries of the complete surface.

Genus-three Ilmanen–White schematic: two reflected curved sheets joined by four smooth necks, with two flaring ends. A second cutaway view exposes the neck walls. Not a computed self-shrinker.
Interactive topology schematic. An upper graph and its reflection join along h + 1 equatorial neck curves and flare into two conical ends. The default genus h = 3 follows the topology of Figure 1 in Ilmanen–White, credited to David Chopp (the paper uses g = h + 1). Rotate, select a genus, or use Cutaway and Equator z = 0 to inspect the necks. This is an original schematic, not Chopp’s numerical surface or a solution of the shrinker equation. Neck shapes, scale and cone slopes are illustrative; both outer rims truncate infinite ends. Open drawing · Numerical references and credits

Ambient space, topology, embeddedness and entropy

Write h for shrinker genus; the source uses a compact wheel of genus g=h+1. This construction is not identified with Ketover’s family.

All genera h ≥ 2 · Euclidean space ℝ³ · Embedded
Ambient space
Euclidean space ℝ³
Topology
Closed orientable genus-h surface with two punctures
Embeddedness
Embedded: The constructed two-ended surfaces are properly embedded for every stated genus.
Compactness
Noncompact
Surface genus
Every integer h ≥ 2
Topological ends
Exactly 2, both asymptotically conical
Entropy
Finite; value not recorded: Finite; an exact value or numerical upper bound is not recorded for this construction.
Gaussian area
Finite; value not recorded: F₀,₁ = λ for the normalized shrinker. Finite; an exact value or numerical upper bound is not recorded for this construction.

Compare examples by these properties →

References on this page

  1. [IlmanenWhite2025] Tom Ilmanen and Brian White. Fattening in mean curvature flow. Ars Inveniendi Analytica, pages Paper No. 4, 32 pp., 2025. Checked arXiv version 3, April 4, 2025; theorem and page locators use this 32-page edition. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18703v3, arXiv:2406.18703, doi:10.15781/cybg-mf32.All uses in this project ↩ 1
Cite this page

Comments

Comments are not enabled yet.