MCF-stack: Special Solutions of Mean Curvature Flow

§ 5.44 Immortal compact flows converging to a double sphere0806DD487DC4

Earliest recorded reference: (first arXiv submission).

Paper credits and chronology

Paper credits are chronological and include every author of the cited papers. They identify sources, not exclusive discovery credit. Background-only citations do not determine the date of this example. A classical example may predate the references recorded here.

  1. Chen–Sun — 2024-02-07 (first arXiv submission).
0806DD487DC4
225751B3C7E8

(Chen–Sun's product-manifold construction) For each $n\geq 2$, there is a smooth connected embedded immortal mean curvature flow of compact hypersurfaces in the product manifold

\[ (S^ n\times [-1,1],\ g_{S^ n}+dy^2), \]

where $S^ n$ has unit round radius. The flow is defined for all $t\geq 0$ and is nonstatic. Its hypersurface dimension is $n$ and its codimension in this ambient manifold is one. The construction stays in the smaller band $|y|\leq 1/(2n)$, so the same flow is contained in $S^ n\times \mathbb R$; it can also be placed in the closed product $S^ n\times (\mathbb R/4\mathbb Z)$ without changing the metric near the flow. There is no free boundary on $y=\pm 1$.

The solution is invariant under rotations of the sphere about its polar axis, reflection $y\mapsto -y$, and reflection across the sphere's equator. A closed profile $\sigma \mapsto (x(\sigma ,t),y(\sigma ,t))$ in $(0,\pi )\times \mathbb R$ generates it by

\[ (\sigma ,\omega )\longmapsto (\cos x(\sigma ,t),\sin x(\sigma ,t)\, \omega ,y(\sigma ,t)), \qquad \sigma \in S^1,\quad \omega \in S^{n-1}. \]

The profile avoids both axes at every finite time, so this parametrization directly gives topology $S^1\times S^{n-1}$. Thus for $n=2$ the surfaces are genus-one tori with no ends. All slices are complete and proper by compactness. This is a topological deduction from the construction, not an assertion that the source states a separate topology theorem.

No closed time-dependent profile is supplied. Its upper half can be described using the solution of

\[ v_ t=\frac{v_{xx}}{1+v_ x^2}+(n-1)\cot x\, v_ x, \qquad v_ x(\pi /2,t)=0, \]

with an inverse graph near each neck, governed by

\[ u_ t=\frac{u_{yy}}{1+u_ y^2}-(n-1)\cot u, \qquad u_ y(0,t)=0. \]

An interpolation argument selects an immortal solution. As $t\to \infty $, it converges to the stable minimal slice $S^ n\times \{ 0\} $ with multiplicity two. Away from the north and south poles, the two sheets converge smoothly; the two necks collapse only at infinite time.

Source: [CS25Man], Theorems 1.1, 3.12, and 3.17, Section 2.1, Definition 3.10 and Lemma 3.11, and Section 3.3, arXiv v2 PDF pp. 1–4 and 11–15. Euclidean Gaussian area and Colding–Minicozzi entropy are not assigned to this intrinsic manifold flow; the cited paper gives no such invariant for these examples. In particular, its isometric embedding into $\mathbb R^{n+2}$ is not an unforced Euclidean mean curvature flow. The picture pairs three ordered finite-time stages with the infinite-time limit and their orbit-space profiles. In the $n=2$ drawing, the coordinate map $(p,y)\mapsto (1+2y)p$, for $p\in S^2$, displays the two sheets as inner and outer shells joined through both polar necks. This map is not an isometry: the radial separation illustrates the product coordinate, not a Euclidean MCF. A display cutaway exposes the inner sheet; its cut edges are not boundaries of the compact surface. The illustrated profiles are smooth schematic loops, not computed solutions or an asserted asymptotic formula. The stage slider assigns no physical times or decay rates. At every finite stage both neck circles remain positive, whereas the separate limit view shows one sphere with multiplicity two.

Three finite-time cutaway tori with two progressively smaller polar necks and closer blue and ochre sheets, followed by one sphere marked multiplicity two. Matching closed orbit-space profiles flatten to a doubled segment. Schematic radial coordinate drawings of a flow in S² × R, not Euclidean MCF.
Qualitative time sequence. Three ordered finite-time stages and the infinite-time double-sphere limit. Blue and ochre sheets join through two polar necks; the profiles below show their approach to y = 0. For n = 2 the radial drawing (p, y) ↦ (1 + 2y)p displays the product coordinate as radial separation and distorts the metric. Cutaway edges are display cuts, not surface boundaries. These are schematic stages, not computed PDE slices; no physical times or decay rates are assigned. Open drawing · Numerical references and credits

Ambient space, topology, embeddedness and entropy

The flow stays in a narrow product band and also fits in a closed Sⁿ × S¹ product. Its Euclidean embedding is not an unforced Euclidean MCF.

Surface flow in S² × ℝ · Riemannian ambient manifold · Embedded
Ambient space
Riemannian ambient manifold
Topology
Torus S¹ × S¹ in S² × ℝ
Embeddedness
Embedded: Each smooth finite-time slice is embedded in the product ambient manifold. The multiplicity-two sphere is only the infinite-time limit.
Compactness
Compact
Surface genus
1
Topological ends
0 (compact)
Entropy
Not applicable: Intrinsic MCF in a curved product manifold; Euclidean entropy / Gaussian area is not assigned.
Gaussian area
Not applicable: Intrinsic MCF in a curved product manifold; Euclidean entropy / Gaussian area is not assigned.
Higher-dimensional product-manifold flows · Riemannian ambient manifold · Embedded
Ambient space
Riemannian ambient manifold
Topology
S¹ × Sⁿ⁻¹ in Sⁿ × ℝ, n ≥ 3
Embeddedness
Embedded: Each smooth finite-time slice is embedded in the product ambient manifold. The multiplicity-two sphere is only the infinite-time limit.
Compactness
Compact
Surface genus
Not a surface
Topological ends
0 (compact)
Entropy
Not applicable: Intrinsic MCF in a curved product manifold; Euclidean entropy / Gaussian area is not assigned.
Gaussian area
Not applicable: Intrinsic MCF in a curved product manifold; Euclidean entropy / Gaussian area is not assigned.

Compare examples by these properties →

References on this page

  1. [CS25Man] Jingwen Chen and Ao Sun. Mean curvature flow with multiplicity 2 convergence in manifolds. Mathematische Annalen, 392(2):1943–1964, 2025. Source locators use arXiv v2, March 9, 2025, 19 pages; the arXiv abstract page adds the word closed to the title, whereas the PDF and published article use in manifolds. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2402.04521v2, doi:10.1007/s00208-025-03147-0.All uses in this project ↩ 1
Cite this page

Comments

Comments are not enabled yet.