MCF-stack: Special Solutions of Mean Curvature Flow

§ 3.21 Translators with an embedded rotational shrinking-torus end (Angenent, 1992; Sun–Zhihan Wang, 2023)C8173134CEA6

Earliest recorded reference: (first arXiv submission).

Paper credits and chronology

Paper credits are chronological and include every author of the cited papers. They identify sources, not exclusive discovery credit. Background-only citations do not determine the date of this example. A classical example may predate the references recorded here.

  1. Angenent — 1992 (publication year). Background only: Constructs the shrinker used as end data, not the translator.
  2. Sun–Zhihan Wang — 2023-01-19 (first arXiv submission).
C8173134CEA6
BF18BDD64F8E

Let $S_ A\subset \mathbb R^3$ be an embedded Angenent self-shrinking torus, normalized by $\vec H_{S_ A}=-X^\perp /2$. Sun–Wang construct complete embedded three-dimensional translators $\Sigma \subset \mathbb R^4=\mathbb R^3_ x\times \mathbb R_ z$ satisfying

\[ \vec H_\Sigma =e_4^\perp ,\qquad M_ t=\Sigma +t e_4,\qquad -\infty <t<\infty . \]

These are variationally constructed hypersurfaces, not explicit parametrized solutions. At sufficiently large height each has the exact graph representation

\[ \Sigma \cap \{ z\geq z_0\} =\left\{ \left(\sqrt z\, [x+u(x,z)\nu _ A(x)],z\right): x\in S_ A,\ z\geq z_0\right\} ,\qquad \| u(\cdot ,z)\| _{C^0(S_ A)}=O(z^{-\epsilon }) \]

for some $\epsilon >0$. The unknown function $u$ is solved for by the construction. In particular, the auxiliary expression obtained by setting $u=0$ is not asserted to be a translator.

  • The translators have codimension one and are smooth, noncompact, complete, and properly embedded. Sun–Wang's general construction can have a singular set of dimension at most $n-7$ for an $n$-dimensional translator in $\mathbb R^{n+1}$; for the present $n=3$ this set is empty.

  • There is a compact core and one end diffeomorphic to $S_ A\times [z_0,\infty )$. Thus a fixed time slice has one topological end, and its sufficiently high horizontal cross-sections have genus one. The translator is a three-manifold: a surface genus is not assigned to it, and the theorem does not identify its compact core as a solid torus.

  • Its unique tangent flow at backward infinity is the multiplicity-one shrinking cylinder generated by $S_ A\times \mathbb R$. Equivalently,

    \[ R^{-1/2}(\Sigma -R e_4)\longrightarrow S_ A\times \mathbb R \quad \hbox{as }R\longrightarrow \infty . \]

    This parabolic blow-down cylinder and the single topological end are different notions.

  • Write $I_ A=\operatorname {ind}_{F}(S_ A)$ for the number of negative eigenvalues of

    \[ -L_{S_ A},\qquad L_{S_ A}=\Delta _{S_ A}-\tfrac 12 X^\top \! \cdot \nabla _{S_ A} +|A_{S_ A}|^2+\tfrac 12, \]

    counted with multiplicity. The translating ends have an $I_ A$-parameter construction, indexed by a ball in $\mathbb R^{I_ A}$ for each sufficiently large cutoff. No exact numerical value of $I_ A$ is needed here. These parameters include ambient translations; they are not a count of parameters after quotienting by rigid motions. The completions need not form a smooth or single-valued family across a fattening parameter. A rotationally invariant subfamily can be chosen.

  • The chosen completions minimize Ilmanen's weighted area $\mathcal I=\int e^ z\, d\mathcal H^3$ locally with their boundary fixed. Consequently they are stable for compactly supported variations of that weighted functional. This statement is not a claim of entropy stability or dynamical stability under mean curvature flow.

  • Their entropy is finite and satisfies the exact identity

    \[ \lambda (\Sigma )=F(S_ A\times \mathbb R)=F(S_ A)=\lambda (S_ A) =\frac1{4\pi }\int _{S_ A}e^{-|x|^2/4}\, d\mathcal H^2. \]

    No closed numerical value or value of $F_{0,1}(\Sigma )$ is supplied by this construction.

  • Nonuniqueness occurs within this same family. There is a rotationally invariant translating end $\Sigma _ e$ for which the associated closed set $T[\Sigma _ e]$ has nonempty interior and

    \[ \partial T[\Sigma _ e]=T^+\sqcup T^-. \]

    The two distinct boundary hypersurfaces are complete smooth embedded $\mathcal I$-minimizing translators, exponentially asymptotic to the same $\Sigma _ e$. Their normalized graph difference decays exponentially in height. This is nonuniqueness of minimizing completions of a fixed end; it is not an assertion that there are exactly two arbitrary translators with that end.

  • For the fixed ball of ends supplied by the construction, the parameters at which fattening occurs form a meager subset. Off that subset there is a unique $\mathcal I$-minimizing completion exponentially asymptotic to the specified end. The uniqueness statement is restricted to this minimizing class and this asymptotic condition.

The original torus is constructed in [Angenent1992], unnumbered theorem on PDF page 1 of the supplied preprint; its original normalization is converted by multiplying the reference immersion by $\sqrt2$. The translator construction is [SunWang2025], Theorems 1.1 and 3.7 (PDF pages 2 and 12), Theorem 4.1 (page 28), and Theorem 4.3 (pages 32–34). The compact-core and single-end statement follows from Lemma 2.5 and the graphical end description in Lemma 3.2 (pages 9–10). The entropy identity is Corollary 2.4 and Lemma 2.5 (pages 8–9). Fattening and its genericity are Theorem 5.1 (page 35, proved on pages 38–39) and Corollary 4.5 (page 34). The construction is not an exhaustive classification, and its realization as a type-II blow-up of a closed flow is stated as Conjecture 4.6 in that paper.

A widening tube in the rotational quotient of the auxiliary end in four-space, and a numerical Angenent torus at the selected height. Copper marks the selected horizontal section. The quotient suppresses the rotation angle; its open rims are display truncations.
Numerical Angenent profile; auxiliary end model. Sun–Wang, Theorem 1.2 and Appendix A: the leading model (√z x, z), x ∈ S_A, with the unknown normal correction set to u = 0. The rotational quotient shows one connected end; the horizontal slice restores the rotation angle to show a torus in ℝ³. Use the height slider to see √z growth, or divide x by √z to see the cylindrical rescaling. The Angenent profile is numerically integrated, not a circular torus. Here h = z/z₀ with an unspecified sufficiently large cutoff z₀; h = 1 is not a tip. The compact core, correction, and fattening pair are not computed. This is not a solved translator. Open drawing · Numerical references and credits

Ambient space, topology, embeddedness and entropy

Genus one belongs to a horizontal surface cross-section, not the three-dimensional translator. The full core topology is not classified.

Compact core with one T² × [z₀,∞) end · Euclidean space ℝ⁴ · Embedded
Ambient space
Euclidean space ℝ⁴
Topology
Compact core with one T² × [z₀,∞) end
Embeddedness
Embedded: The constructed three-dimensional translators in ℝ⁴ are properly embedded.
Compactness
Noncompact
Surface genus
Not a surface: translator dimension 3
Topological ends
1 topological end
Entropy
Exact formula: λ(Σ) = λ(S_A) = F₀,₁(S_A). Exact relation to the input Angenent torus; no exact numerical value.
Gaussian area
Not recorded: Not recorded for the stated center and scale.

Compare examples by these properties →

References on this page

  1. [Angenent1992] Sigurd B. Angenent. Shrinking doughnuts. In Nonlinear Diffusion Equations and Their Equilibrium States, 3, volume 7 of Progress in Nonlinear Differential Equations and Their Applications, pages 21–38. Birkhäuser, Boston, MA, 1992.All uses in this project ↩ 1
  2. [SunWang2025] Ao Sun and Zhihan Wang. On mean curvature flow translators with prescribed ends. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 2025. Source locators refer to arXiv version 2, posted 20 August 2025, 45 pages. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.08224v2, arXiv:2301.08224, doi:10.1007/s00205-025-02125-9.All uses in this project ↩ 1
Cite this page

Comments

Comments are not enabled yet.